Assessing the potential of an early-stage startup is difficult because there is no stable cash flow on which to base a forecast. Comparative assessment is nevertheless possible. After reviewing many technology companies, including businesses evaluated for the Bloomio crowdfunding platform, we developed the following method for measuring early-stage potential.
The review begins with three dimensions: People, Product and Process. These are extended by Innovation, Technology and Engineering Delivery. The final perspective is the Customer: how the startup creates the greatest possible value for the organizations and people it serves.

The process starts with high-level information, usually supplied by management. It should then be complemented by confidential one-to-one interviews across the team. Ideally, everyone should be heard. Carefully selected questions often reveal a picture that differs from the official management view.
The questions are grouped as follows:
- Team. The founders’ managerial and technical capabilities, their actual commitment and whether the team is sufficient to develop the product.
- Market potential. The size of the opportunity, target audience and competitive landscape.
- Innovation. Innovation potential, the process for creating new solutions and intellectual-property protection.
- Product state. Product and business readiness, roadmaps and demonstrated progress.
- Process maturity. Engineering operations, customer support and the ability to anticipate issues and respond to risk.
The collected answers are reviewed by a technical due-diligence expert. Each group receives a score from 1 — poor — to 5 — outstanding.
A startup-rating example

- 5 — Outstanding. Clearly exceeds industry standards and comparable companies.
- 4 — Very good. Above average relative to similar businesses.
- 3 — Good. In line with the average company in the domain.
- 2 — Modest. Partly below industry standards.
- 1 — Poor. Clear need for substantial improvement.
The average of the group scores produces a final number from 1 to 5. This indicator provides a consistent basis for comparing the potential of early-stage companies.
Early-stage ratings from AAA to C

In the example above, the average score is 3.2, corresponding to BBB+: a good startup.
The rating is not a substitute for an investment decision and should never be its only input. It creates a common language for comparison and helps an investment team view potential targets from an additional perspective.
