STARTUP RATING · 2023

Early-Stage Startup Rating Methodology

Team, market, innovation, product and process maturity are scored from 1 to 5 and mapped to an AAA–C rating.

Early-stage startup rating methodology

Assessing the potential of an early-stage startup is difficult because there is no stable cash flow on which to base a forecast. Comparative assessment is nevertheless possible. After reviewing many technology companies, including businesses evaluated for the Bloomio crowdfunding platform, we developed the following method for measuring early-stage potential.

The review begins with three dimensions: People, Product and Process. These are extended by Innovation, Technology and Engineering Delivery. The final perspective is the Customer: how the startup creates the greatest possible value for the organizations and people it serves.

Technology-startup assessment model
People, Product and Process form the core; Innovation, Technology, Engineering Delivery and Customer value extend the assessment.

The process starts with high-level information, usually supplied by management. It should then be complemented by confidential one-to-one interviews across the team. Ideally, everyone should be heard. Carefully selected questions often reveal a picture that differs from the official management view.

The questions are grouped as follows:

  • Team. The founders’ managerial and technical capabilities, their actual commitment and whether the team is sufficient to develop the product.
  • Market potential. The size of the opportunity, target audience and competitive landscape.
  • Innovation. Innovation potential, the process for creating new solutions and intellectual-property protection.
  • Product state. Product and business readiness, roadmaps and demonstrated progress.
  • Process maturity. Engineering operations, customer support and the ability to anticipate issues and respond to risk.

The collected answers are reviewed by a technical due-diligence expert. Each group receives a score from 1 — poor — to 5 — outstanding.

A startup-rating example

Startup rating radar chart
Example of a five-dimension startup assessment.
  • 5 — Outstanding. Clearly exceeds industry standards and comparable companies.
  • 4 — Very good. Above average relative to similar businesses.
  • 3 — Good. In line with the average company in the domain.
  • 2 — Modest. Partly below industry standards.
  • 1 — Poor. Clear need for substantial improvement.

The average of the group scores produces a final number from 1 to 5. This indicator provides a consistent basis for comparing the potential of early-stage companies.

Early-stage ratings from AAA to C

AAA to C startup-rating scale
The average score is mapped to an AAA–C letter rating.

In the example above, the average score is 3.2, corresponding to BBB+: a good startup.

The rating is not a substitute for an investment decision and should never be its only input. It creates a common language for comparison and helps an investment team view potential targets from an additional perspective.

Related service

Technical due diligence and startup rating

Open startup assessment Technical due diligence and startup rating → Discuss a project